Review : Silkygirl Funky Eyelights Pencil + Comparison with NYX & Urban Decay!

Hi bubblies!

How's everything going?

Hope you're doing magnificent! :D

Here's my in depth review for the  

Silkygirl Funky Eyelights Pencil 

that was on my previous post the other day --> click here!

With these, I also compare the quality with other similar items from NYX and Urban Decay, which already famous and known for their quality.

in clockwise order :

Silkygirl Funky Eyelights Pencil in 04 Pure Purple

Silkygirl Funky Eyelights Pencil in 06 Metallic Bronze

NYX Slide On Pencil in SL04 Pure White

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils in Mildew

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils in Ransom

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils in Binge

Let's get started!

***

 

 

*Color Pay Off : Pigmentation & Texture

All of these products are a high quality one. They glide on nicely, smoothly and very pigmented. The color you get is as opaque as you would imagine, or some.. maybe better! With variety of different finishes they offer, you'll blown away by all of these gorgeousness. ( is that a word? lol. ) :D

Swatches!

no primer. no base.

indoor artificial light

 outdoor day sunlight

 

Pigmentation >> Urban Decay ♥♥♥♥♥ , NYX ♥♥♥♥♥ , Silkygirl ♥♥♥♥♥

 

Texture wise.. I have to say, UD is the most creamiest of them all. It feels buttery and melt easily, it goes on like a dream. *_* While Silkygirl and NYX may not as creamy as UD, but still.. it goes on smoothly, nicely and easy to blend or to work with. 

Creaminess >> Urban Decay ♥♥♥♥♥ , NYX ♥♥♥♥♡ , Silkygirl ♥♥♥♥♡

*Staying Power & Performance : 
Smudgeproof? Waterproof? Fadeproof?

While UD felt more creamy than the rest of those two, however.. NYX and SG felt stickier. ( << and that's why they stick better on my skin! ) You can conclude, in this case, to me personal, I prefer NYX or SG over UD! wuow. surprise surprise! :P

Rubbing Test :

in this picture, after it set, I rub them twice.

As you can see, UD fade the most, while SG just a little, but NYX! oh my.. it stays put! 0.0

Smudgeproof >> Urban Decay ♥♥♥♡♡ , NYX ♥♥♥♥♥ , Silkygirl ♥♥♥♥♡

Water Test :

in this picture, I let the water runs through them, and wow again.. they all stay put!

Waterproof >> Urban Decay ♥♥♥♥♥ , NYX ♥♥♥♥♥ , Silkygirl ♥♥♥♥♥

Another Test ( Water + Rub ) :

In this picture below, I let them stay wet and again, try to rub them.

rub them once :(

rub them twice :"(

I think the idea of waterproof are they can't be rubbed at the same time, because you will loose some of the staying power that they give at first. SO, moral story : you can cry with these, It will stay put.. BUT, you can't wipe your tears. 

if you wanna cry, CRY with pride!

*lol.

About the staying power on my lid..
UD fade the most through a couple of hours, while NYX and SG will stay vibrant longer! :D

Fadeproof >> Urban Decay ♥♥♥♥♡ , NYX ♥♥♥♥♥ , Silkygirl ♥♥♥♥♥

*Price Range & Color Range

Urban Decay has 24 gorgeous colors selection, with $19 each. 

( www.urbandecay.com ) 

NYX has 18 colors selection total, with $8 each. 

( www.nyxcosmetics.com) 

while Silkygirl has 12 awesome colors, with roughly $4 each. 

( www.silkycosmetics.co )

I guess.. to me, the cheapest kinda beats by the price. I mean, I prefer more NYX and Silkygirl by their staying power, but I couldn't resist that Urban Decay also have my heart by their color selection :) ♥

*Silkygirl Funky Eyelights Pencil in 04 Pure Purple VS Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils in Ransom

Maybe in my previous post that I mention earlier, I also said that SG04 Pure Purple would be a great dupe for UD Liner in Ransom. Well, $4 against $19.. hemmm Let's see! :D

If you take a look closely..

UD Ransom has the reflective sheen almost metallic that makes it unique.

While SG Pure Purple just has a satin finish with a deep plum purple color.

But, with different angle it's just slightly almost the same.

When you put it in your eyes ( as your eyeliner or eyeshadow base ), UD Liner in Ransom could brighten up your eyes or any eyeshadow you put on top.. While Silkygirl just makes a gorgeous purple color. 

BUT, not hurt to have this as a backup if you like Ransom so much, right?

That's what I do! lol.

***

 

So, have you tried any Silkygirl product?

What is your favorite?

Let me know what you think!

I'd love to hear from you. :)

Good day all!

Smile :)

NOTE: all of the product were purchased by my own money and reviewed by honest thought. It's just my way to give you an opinion in buying product that you considered to purchase. Be a smart buyer! Hope you like my reviews.